Process
How federal IDR works
The No Surprises Act created a federal independent dispute resolution process for certain out-of-network payment disputes. The steps and deadlines below are taken from CMS, not from marketing copy. Always confirm current instructions on the CMS IDR pages, because the Departments can issue extensions or operational updates.
When a provider or facility receives an initial payment or a notice of denial of payment from a plan for a qualifying out-of-network item or service, either party may start open negotiation. Either party may initiate open negotiation within 30 business days of receiving that payment or denial. Source: CMS, About Independent Dispute Resolution; Federal IDR Process Guidance for Disputing Parties.
The open negotiation period lasts 30 business days (Monday through Friday, not including federal holidays). A dispute generally cannot go to IDR until this period has ended. Parties may settle during this window and avoid IDR fees. Source: CMS, About Independent Dispute Resolution.
If the parties do not agree on a payment amount, either party may begin the Federal IDR process. A dispute cannot be initiated until the 30-business-day open negotiation period has ended, and must be initiated within 4 business days after that period has ended, except when the Departments grant an extension. Source: CMS, About Independent Dispute Resolution.
The parties may agree on a certified IDR entity from the CMS list. If they do not agree, the Departments select one. CMS materials describe a 3-business-day window for entity selection after initiation. Source: CMS certified IDR entity selection materials and disputing-party guidance.
Each party submits a payment offer and supporting information. The certified IDR entity must select one of the two offers as the out-of-network rate. It may not split the difference or invent a third number. CMS calls this “baseball-style” or “selection of offer” arbitration. The determination is binding unless there is fraud or intentional misrepresentation of material facts. Source: Federal IDR Process Guidance for Disputing Parties, section on selection of offer; CMS, About Independent Dispute Resolution.
Not later than 30 business days after the certified IDR entity’s selection is finalized, the entity must choose one offer, notify the parties and the Departments, and provide a written decision. Source: Federal IDR Process Guidance for Disputing Parties.
The parties must abide by the decision, and payment must be made within 30 calendar days. Source: CMS, About Independent Dispute Resolution.
What federal IDR applies to — and what it does not
Federal IDR may be used to determine the out-of-network rate for certain qualified items and services, including emergency services (and certain post-stabilization services), non-emergency items and services furnished by out-of-network providers at certain in-network facilities, and out-of-network air ambulance services. It does not apply to items and services payable by Medicare, Medicaid, CHIP, or TRICARE.
Federal IDR also does not apply when a specified state law or an All-Payer Model Agreement already provides a method for determining the out-of-network rate for that plan, provider, and service. Self-funded ERISA plans generally use the federal process, except where a plan has validly opted into a state process that allows opt-in. CMS publishes a state-by-state applicability chart (the public chart states it is current as of January 11, 2023, and may be updated).
- Arizona: CMS lists Arizona under the Federal IDR Process. CMS’s February 23, 2022 enforcement letter concluded that A.R.S. §§ 20-3111 through 20-3119 is not a specified state law, so federal IDR applies to determining the out-of-network rate for covered items and services in Arizona. Sources: CMS Federal IDR Applicability Chart; CMS letter to Arizona.
- Texas: CMS lists Texas under the bifurcated process. For many fully insured, TDI-regulated plans — including out-of-network diagnostic imaging performed in connection with in-network care — Texas Insurance Code Chapter 1467 is a specified state law, so those disputes go through the Texas mediation/arbitration system, not federal IDR. Federal IDR still applies to air ambulance and to plans that are not covered by the Texas process (including many self-funded ERISA plans that have not opted in). Eligibility has to be checked claim by claim. Sources: CMS Federal IDR Applicability Chart; CMS letter to Texas; Texas Department of Insurance, Balance billing: Independent Dispute Resolution.
CMS has also moved dispute filing into the IDR Gateway. As of November 13, 2026, IDR Gateway users can submit Notice of IDR Initiation and related forms in the Gateway; CMS has stated that single-use web forms will no longer be available outside the Gateway after January 15, 2027. Confirm the current filing method on CMS before you file.
How ARBMD works with this process
Once engaged, we screen for eligibility, run open negotiation, file in the federal portal when a claim belongs there, prepare the offer package, and track every deadline through payment. If a claim belongs in a state process instead of federal IDR, we will say so rather than file in the wrong venue.
Our work is contingency-based: you pay only if we recover. Terms are set in the written engagement. Administrative and certified IDR entity fees charged by the federal process are separate and are addressed in that agreement.